Guidelines for Reviewers
The iRASD Journal of Energy & Environment (iRASD-JEE) recognizes the essential contribution of peer reviewers in maintaining scholarly quality, research integrity, and academic credibility. The journal follows a double-blind peer-review process and expects reviewers to provide independent, objective, confidential, constructive, and evidence-based evaluations of manuscripts.
1. Review Invitations and Deadlines
Reviewers should accept an invitation only when they possess the relevant expertise, can provide an impartial evaluation, and are reasonably able to complete the assessment within the assigned period.
The journal's standard reviewer deadlines are:
-
Response to Review Invitation: Two weeks (14 calendar days) to accept or decline an invitation.
-
Review Completion: Four weeks (28 calendar days) to complete the initial manuscript evaluation.
The specific response and review completion dates are communicated through Open Journal Systems (OJS) and may be adjusted by the handling editor where justified.
Reviewers who anticipate delays should promptly inform the handling editor and request an extension where necessary. Reviewers unable to undertake an assignment should decline promptly to facilitate the appointment of an alternative reviewer.
These deadlines apply to reviewer assignments and do not represent guaranteed editorial decision or publication times.
2. Confidentiality and Competing Interests
All manuscripts, supplementary materials, review reports, and related editorial communications must be treated as confidential.
Reviewers must not share unpublished materials, disclose confidential information, use manuscript content for personal advantage, or contact authors directly regarding manuscripts under evaluation.
Under the double-blind review process, reviewers should not attempt to identify the authors or disclose their own identities in comments intended for authors.
Any involvement of colleagues or trainees in a review requires prior authorization from the handling editor.
Reviewers must disclose actual, potential, or perceived competing interests and decline assignments where their impartiality could be compromised.
Reviewers must comply with the journal's Conflict of Interest Policy and Generative AI and AI-Assisted Technologies Policy, including restrictions on uploading confidential manuscript materials to unauthorized AI systems.
3. Manuscript Evaluation Criteria
Reviewers should assess manuscripts objectively and constructively, considering the following aspects where applicable:
-
Relevance to the journal's aims and scope.
-
Originality, scientific significance, and scholarly contribution.
-
Adequacy of the theoretical or conceptual framework.
-
Appropriateness and rigor of the research methodology.
-
Quality, validity, and reliability of data and analysis.
-
Accuracy and interpretation of results.
-
Consistency between research objectives, findings, and conclusions.
-
Compliance with relevant research ethics requirements.
-
Clarity and accuracy of tables, figures, and supplementary materials.
-
Adequacy and relevance of scholarly references.
-
Organization, clarity, and overall academic presentation.
Reviewers should distinguish significant scientific or methodological concerns from minor presentation and formatting issues. Any essential supplementary information required for evaluation should be requested through the handling editor.
4. Review Reports and Recommendations
Review reports should be clear, respectful, evidence-based, and constructive.
Comments to Authors: Reviewers should identify major strengths and weaknesses, explain concerns, and provide specific recommendations for improvement. Personal criticism, discriminatory remarks, and inappropriate language are not acceptable.
Confidential Comments to the Editor: Reviewers may report concerns relating to research integrity, competing interests, confidentiality, or other sensitive matters requiring editorial attention. Comments that could reasonably assist authors should ordinarily be included in the report shared with them.
Recommendations: Reviewers should select the appropriate recommendation available in OJS and provide a reasoned justification. Reviewers' recommendations are advisory; final editorial decisions remain the responsibility of authorized editors.
Reviewers should submit their completed assessments through OJS by the assigned deadline.
5. References and Research Integrity
Reviewers should evaluate whether references are relevant, appropriate, and sufficient to support the manuscript.
Requests for additional citations must be academically justified. Reviewers must not seek unnecessary citations to their own work, the journal's publications, or other sources for personal or institutional benefit.
Suspected plagiarism, duplicate publication, data fabrication or manipulation, unethical research practices, compromised peer review, or other potential misconduct should be reported confidentially to the handling editor.
Reviewers should not independently investigate allegations or contact authors regarding suspected misconduct.
Such concerns are handled under the journal's established Publication Ethics and Complaints, Appeals, and Misconduct policies.
6. Professional Conduct and Further Guidance
Reviewers are expected to maintain high standards of professional conduct, confidentiality, impartiality, and timely communication throughout the review process.
Review quality and scientific integrity must not be compromised to meet administrative deadlines.
Reviewers requiring clarification regarding an assignment, review procedures, ethical concerns, or deadlines should contact the handling editor through OJS.
Related Policies
iRASD-JEE values the contribution of independent reviewers and remains committed to a fair, rigorous, confidential, and transparent scholarly evaluation process.


